Documenting Short-Term Rental Hours Is the Key to Surviving an Audit: The Do's and Don'ts of the Short-Term Rental Loophole
E34

Documenting Short-Term Rental Hours Is the Key to Surviving an Audit: The Do's and Don'ts of the Short-Term Rental Loophole

You bought the short term rental. You ran the cost segregation study. Your CPA says the loss can offset your W-2 income, as long as you materially participated. Then the IRS asks you to prove it.

This episode is the other half of Heidi’s earlier deep dive on active versus passive income. Heidi Henderson sits down with Aaron deSouza, CPA, co-founder of Make It Deductible. Aaron spent more than 30 years in audit at PwC, Deloitte, and Grant Thornton. When he started investing in short term rentals and equipment himself, someone handed him an Excel spreadsheet and told him it would cover him. His auditor brain said otherwise, so he built the documentation system he couldn’t find.

His approach is simple. Text three things while you work: what you did, how long it took, and a picture. Add the purpose, outcome, or decision behind it. A human reviews it and coaches you on what’s missing, then AI turns it into a memo with four parts: the business, the event, the tax view in IRS language, and the evidence.

Aaron explains what contemporaneous documentation really means and why most spreadsheets fail. He shares the story of an IRS agent who checked when a spreadsheet was created and found it was made a few weeks before the audit, not three years earlier when the work was supposed to have happened. He walks through what counts and what doesn’t. Pricing decisions, meeting the plumber, decorating, and setting up your calendar usually count. Reviewing loan documents, researching properties, and travel that doubles as a vacation usually don’t. He also explains how some of those tasks can move into the gray area when they tie directly to an operating decision.

Heidi shares what a cost segregation audit typically looks like when the documentation is solid, and why a large deduction on its own isn’t usually what triggers one. They finish with practical advice for investors who bought a short term rental late in the year and still need 100 real hours before December 31.

KEY TOPICS
What material participation means and why it decides whether your loss is active or passive | The 100 hour and more than anyone else rule for short term rentals | Why the burden of proof is on the taxpayer, not your CPA or cost seg provider | What contemporaneous documentation is and why spreadsheets fail | The POD method: purpose, outcome, or decision | Activities that count and activities that don’t | How travel and financing tasks can move into the gray area | Why to aim for 150 hours instead of 100 | Recording tasks that don’t count to show you’re building a real business | What an audit looks like when your records are organized | How to hit 100 hours after a Q4 purchase | Why the investment should come first and the tax benefit second

ABOUT AARON DESOUZA
Aaron deSouza, CPA is an accounting and audit professional, entrepreneur, and co-founder of Make It Deductible AI, with more than 30 years of experience at leading accounting firms including PwC, Deloitte, and Grant Thornton. At Grant Thornton he served as a Partner and U.S. Audit Leader for Private Equity, advising businesses on complex audits, mergers and acquisitions, and financial reporting. Drawing on that experience and his own investments in real estate and equipment, Aaron co-founded Make It Deductible to help investors create organized, CPA-ready documentation of their business activities through AI, human review, and personal coaching. He is also the founder of ControlOwner, Inc. and serves as a TIGER 21 Chair in Atlanta.

CONNECT WITH AARON DESOUZA & MAKE IT DEDUCTIBLE
Website: https://makeitdeductible.ai
Email: team@makeitdeductible.ai
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/aaronfdesouza

Resources:
Get A Free Cost Segregation Benefit Analysis Here:
https://portal.engineeredtaxservices.com/get-started?ref_id=njg2zdv

IRS Audit Technique Guidelines:
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p5653.pdf

Baselane Affiliate Link:
https://baselane.com/engineeredtaxservices

Baselane Promo Code: ENGINEERING6
Use promo code ENGINEERING6 to receive 6 months of free Baselane Smart premium tier. Enter the code when prompted to subscribe to Baselane Smart.

Links:
LinkedIn - linkedin.com/in/heidihenderson
Instagram - instagram.com/slashtaxwithheidi
Facebook - facebook.com/slashtaxwithheidi
https://app.411core.com/r/XCB

LEARN MORE
Engineered Tax Services has helped investors and business owners unlock millions in tax savings for nearly 25 years through cost segregation, R&D credits, and energy incentives like 179D and 45L.
👉 Visit engineeredtaxservices.com

Nothing in this episode is tax, legal, or investment advice. Talk with your CPA about your situation.

Subscribe to Slash Tax | Leave a review | Share with an investor who just bought their first short term rental

TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Highlights
00:30 Introduction
03:46 What Make It Deductible does
04:56 Text three things: what, how long, and a picture
06:15 The POD method and the four part memo
09:11 Why the burden of proof is on you
10:31 Material participation and the 100 hour rule
13:27 What the IRS looks for in an audit
16:22 The spreadsheet that failed an audit
17:40 Activities that don’t count
18:16 Activities that do count
19:56 The gray areas: travel and financing
25:43 Aaron’s story: from Big Four auditor to founder
29:35 AI with a human in the loop
32:48 Why aim for 150 hours
33:18 What a cost seg audit really looks like
38:26 Bought a short term rental in Q4?
42:53 How to reach Aaron

Episode Video